Fishing19

Fishing Nicks Lake

Checked against NYS DEC on

Nicks Lake is a water in Herkimer County, New York, that New York State Department of Environmental Conservation stocks with fish.

WhereHerkimer CountyNew York
Stocked in 20261,800 fishbrown trout

Map

The map searches Google for "Nicks Lake, Herkimer County, NY". Check that the pin is the right water before you drive. Copy location gives you a link to open in your own maps app.

Fish stocked in 2026

FishNumberSize
Brown trout1,8008 in

From the NYS DEC yearly stocking reports, 2026. Most of these trout are yearlings of 8 to 10 inches; the 12 to 15 inch fish are two-year-olds. All are catchable size when they go in.

All New York stocking by fish

Limits and license

We have not checked whether this water has its own limits. Unless a sign or the NYS DEC rules say otherwise, the statewide limits apply.

New York statewide bag and length limits · New York license prices · Fishing here? Price your license

Other stocked waters in Herkimer County

Beardsley Lake Fourth Lake Moss Lake Old Forge Pond Otsquago Creek Prospect Reservoir Quiver Pond Spruce Creek Sunday Creek Third Lake Twitchell Lake Unadilla River